The play: offer the piece that completes what they just bought: the lead in the same colour and width as the harness, the treats after the food, the refill rolls after the dispenser. Get the match right and the offer feels like service, not selling. It's light, so it rides in the same parcel.
What it's worth
Here is the pet store from our scoreboard. Modelled, conservative, arithmetic in plain sight. Put your own numbers through the calculator.
Pet brand doing €430k a month
+€6,246a month
That's €75k a year in extra revenue, on the same ad spend.
| Orders a month | 8,269 |
| × paid by card or Shop Pay (70%) | 5,788 eligible |
| × take the offer (6.0%) | 347 add-ons |
| × average add-on (€18) | €6,246 a month |
Illustrative store, modelled figures. Not a client result. Gross add-on sales across all eligible orders, before the 10% holdout. Your real numbers come out of the audit.
Three numbers do the work. 70% eligible: the share of orders paid by card or Shop Pay, the methods Shopify shows one-click offers for. An assumption we check on your store. 6.0% take rate: we model pet higher than apparel because a lead that matches the harness is an obvious yes. Still inside the 4–6.5% range we use. €18 add-on: the lead, at full price.
And the parcel barely changes. A lead weighs next to nothing, so the add-on costs you almost nothing extra to ship.
The other 30% still count. Apple Pay, Google Pay, Klarna, iDEAL and bank transfer can't be charged again automatically, so Shopify skips the one-click page for them. Most setups stop there. We don't: those buyers get an offer on the thank-you page and pay with a quick new payment. They're left out of the sum above, which keeps it conservative.
What would your pet store add?
We read your payment mix, bestsellers and sizes, then tell you the first offer we'd test. Fifteen minutes.
No setup fee. No retainer. You only pay from the profit we add.
Six offers to test
Every pet offer lives or dies on the match: size, width, species, diet. The suppress column matters as much as the offer.
| They bought | Offer | Suppress when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| A harness | The lead in the same colour and width | A lead is in the basket, or they bought one in the last 12 months | Width must suit the harness size: slim for XS–S, wider for L–XL |
| Dry food | The treats their dog gets next, same protein | Treats are in the basket | Diet: no chicken treats after a chicken-free or hypoallergenic food |
| A poop bag dispenser | Refill rolls | Refills are in the basket | The roll size must fit that dispenser |
| A dog bed | A spare washable cover in the same size | A cover is in the basket | Size and shape must match exactly; a round bed needs a round cover |
| Cat litter | Litter tray liners or a scoop | Liners or a scoop are in the basket, or were bought recently | Not a second bag of litter: the weight pushes up shipping on the add-on |
| A puppy harness or puppy food | Training treats or a chew toy for that age | Bought in the last 30 days | Puppies grow fast; don't offer the next size up yet |
Illustrative example, modelled figures.
Start with row one. It's the cleanest match in the category, every harness has exactly one right answer, and it's the offer a buyer would otherwise go looking for next week, somewhere else.
What kills it in pet
Compatibility and sizes
Every pet product has a size, and most accessories only work with one. A 25 mm lead on an XS harness looks wrong and goes back. Map every harness to its lead, every dispenser to its rolls, every bed to its cover. If a product has no clean match, it gets no offer.
Things they already own
Pet owners come back, and your best customers bought the lead last spring. Check the basket at minimum; where your data allows, suppress anything bought in the last year. An offer for something they own wastes a slot (a buyer can accept at most three offers per checkout) and tells them you don't know them.
The wrong animal, the wrong diet
A cat owner shown dog treats. A grain-free buyer shown grain treats. Tag products by species and diet before any offer goes live, and treat multi-pet orders with care: offer for the animal the main item was for.
Weight
Food and litter are heavy. Shipping and tax for the add-on are calculated from the delivery address and shown before the buyer accepts, so a heavy add-on shows a heavy price. Keep add-ons light.
The first four weeks
- Week 1. Harness → lead, same colour and width, full price. 10% of eligible orders are held out and never see an offer.
- Week 2. Food → treats that match the diet.
- Week 3. The lead at full price vs 15% off. Keep the one that earns more per eligible order.
- Week 4. Read the holdout. Keep, change or kill each offer.
That loop runs every week, with a scorecard in Slack every Monday. We take this exact offer apart in Keep or kill? Harness and lead. The measuring method: holdout testing for upsells.
FAQ
Can I offer a food subscription after payment?
Not by converting the order: Shopify doesn't let a one-time purchase become a subscription after payment. You can offer a separate subscription product with the buyer's clear consent, unless the order already contains a subscription or has no shipping address.
How do I stop offering a lead to someone who already has one?
Two layers. Check the basket: a lead in the order means no lead offer. Then, where your data allows, check past orders and suppress anything bought in the last year. We set both up before the first offer goes live.
What's the first pet offer to test?
Harness to lead, same colour and width. It's the cleanest match in the category and light enough to ride in the same parcel. We break it down, keep-or-kill style, on our scoreboard page.
Other categories: Apparel Home & living Outdoor & sport Coffee All industries
Stop at “thank you”? Or offer the lead.
We build, run and test your post-purchase and thank-you page offers for you. Live within 48 hours of access and approval. No setup fee, no retainer.
Free 15-minute call. For Shopify brands doing €100k+ a month.